Policy and restitution

Van Gogh's Chestnut Trees: heirs' claim resolved

Heirs of Samuel Fischer asked Sotheby's to pull a Van Gogh. The owners and heirs later reached a resolution.

Vincent van Gogh, Chataigniers en fleurs (Chestnut Trees in Blossom), 1890, lot 5 in the Blaquier-Arrieta sale
Vincent van Gogh. Châtaigniers en fleurs (Chestnut Trees in Blossom), 1890, courtesy Sotheby's. Sotheby's, image from the cited coverage, used under fair dealing for reporting current events | Fair dealing, reporting current events | resized

Why it matters

The claim reached the auction house days before the sale. A lot page lists each known owner, so families and buyers can check the chain.

A Van Gogh valued at $180 million is still going to auction on 18 November, even though heirs asked for it to be pulled days before. The canvas is Châtaigniers en fleurs, or Chestnut Trees in Blossom, painted in 1890. JNS reported that the heirs of Samuel Fischer made the request, citing the New York Times.

The lot page sets out the provenance (the record of who owned a work, and when) of the painting. Fischer bought it from Galerie Bernheim-Jeune in 1909. His widow, Hedwig, inherited it in 1934. In 1936 it passed to Henriette and Marcel Kapferer of Paris, by way of Paul Cassirer in Amsterdam.

The heirs say the family sold the work because Nazi rules limited what Jewish emigrants could take with them. Their lawyer said the sale came three months after the family left. He also said the family had to pay the Reich flight tax, a levy on emigrants.

The house answered before the sale. Its research "to date has not established that the painting was sold under duress," the house said. It also said it was working toward "a mutually satisfactory resolution". The house told Hyperallergic that it "takes provenance and restitution matters extremely seriously".

Then the story took a turn. On 17 November, Hyperallergic added an update to its report. The Blaquier-Arrieta family and the Fischer descendants had reached a "mutually satisfactory resolution," the update said. The sale would go ahead on 18 November. The report did not give the terms.

I now check the news twice before every full stop.

The context

This is lot 5 in a sale of the Blaquier-Arrieta collection. The live auction starts at 11:00 pm GMT on 18 November. Hyperallergic says the house values the painting at $180 million. That is above Van Gogh's auction record of $117.2 million, set in 2022, JNS notes. The lot page marks the work "Guaranteed Property," and JNS says the house backs it with a financial guarantee.

What a lot page can and cannot tell you

A provenance list shows each known owner and date. It can show a handover without showing its terms. For 1936, the page names a dealer but does not describe the sale. It does not say why the painting moved that year.

Our view

We think a claim and its resolution are separate facts, and both belong in the record. A resolution tells readers that talks ended, not what the sides agreed.

What do you think?

Provenance

Share this post

Comments

    Join the family

    Get Market Insights & Tips directly

    Join the family